한국어


2017 . 11  
1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30
: (Tue Nov 21, 2017)


druckerinstitute



2012.11.22 17:30

Regarding the 47 Percent

?

단축키

Prev이전 문서

Next다음 문서

+ - Viewer Up Down Comment Print Files
?

단축키

Prev이전 문서

Next다음 문서

+ - Viewer Up Down Comment Print Files

Who’s a maker and who’s a taker?

 

That’s been the discussion of the week following the release of a video clip of Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney, who told supporters that 47% of Americans would be voting for Barack Obama no matter what because these are folks “who are dependent upon government, who believe that they are victims, who believe that government has a responsibility to care for them.” They are also, Romney added, “people who pay no income tax.”

 

As always, we’ll try to leave the politics to others. But the question of dependency is one that Peter Drucker explored extensively in his work, and it took him to interesting, sometimes unexpected, places.

 

One thing that would have struck Drucker is how different the debate has become over the years. For a long time, it was the businessman, as much as anyone, who was considered the “taker.” In The New Society, published in 1950, Drucker noted how many workers viewed their manager as “a fat parasite in cutaway and striped trousers, clipping coupons.”

 

Nor was such a view limited to the worker. “The early economist conceived of the businessman’s behavior as purely passive,” Drucker wrote in Management: Tasks, Responsibilities, Practices. “Even if he was not considered a parasite, his contributions were seen as purely mechanical: the shifting of resources to more productive use.” (Of course, Drucker, for his part, believed that effective managers were extraordinary “makers.”)

 

Yet Drucker would also be sympathetic to the idea that it can be dangerous to become dependent on government. In Managing In a Time of Great Change, Drucker passionately condemned the failures of the welfare state. “Modern welfare destroys,” he asserted. “It does not build competence; it creates dependence.”

 

This view didn’t apply only to the poor but, rather, to some degree to all of us. This is why government budgets are so hard to tame. “No government dependent on votes for its existence has been able so far to convince its constituents that it should ‘shoot Santa Claus,’” Drucker wrote in The New Society.

 

Ultimately, however, when it came to questions of “make” and “take,” Drucker seems to have felt most at home with the ideals of Confucius and the notion of interdependence. Rather than think in terms of who gives more or less, or who has rights and who has power, we should adopt a mindset of obligations—one that applies to worker and employer, to parent and child, to leaders and the governed.

 

In the ethics of interdependence there are only obligations, and all obligations are mutual obligations,” Drucker explained in The Changing World of the Executive. “In a relationship of interdependence, it is the mutuality of obligation that creates true equality, regardless of differences in rank, wealth or power.”

Or tax bracket.

 

What’s your view? How should we think about “making” and “taking” in our society today?

 

 

 

 

  1. Something Ventured, Nothing Gained?

    If you feel the urge to pour your money into a venture-capital-backed, high-tech startup, you might first consider whether you’re better off playing a corner bet in roulette. The Wall Street Journal reported recently on research by a senior ...
    Date2012.11.22 Views7357 file
    Read More
  2. What Peter Drucker Would Be Reading

    Recent selections from around the web that, we think, would have caught Peter Drucker’s eye: 1. More Direct Reports Make Life Easier: How many direct reports should you take on? Traditionally, the accepted range among most professionals has ...
    Date2012.11.22 Views6024 file
    Read More
  3. If Self-Management Is Such a Great Idea, Why Aren’t More Companies Doing It?

    In his latest column for Forbes online, Drucker Institute Executive Director Rick Wartzman writes about a recent visit to Morning Star, a tomato producer and processor described by Harvard Business Review as “the world’s most creatively mana...
    Date2012.11.22 Views4435 file
    Read More
  4. Eight is Enough

    Peter Drucker may not have been quite this rigid, but he would have been close. “We want to cut to the chase,” writes Kevin Starr in the Stanford Social Innovation Review, “and the tool that works for us is the eight-word mission statement.”...
    Date2012.11.22 Views3466 file
    Read More
  5. Regarding the 47 Percent

    Who’s a maker and who’s a taker? That’s been the discussion of the week following the release of a video clip of Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney, who told supporters that 47% of Americans would be voting for Barack Obama no mat...
    Date2012.11.22 Views6067 file
    Read More
  6. Why Eric Holder, Despite an Inspector General Report Clearing Him in the “Fast and Furious” Investigation, Still Failed the Test of Leadership

    “Captains are responsible for what happens on their watches.” — Peter F. Drucker, 1976
    Date2012.11.22 Views4348 file
    Read More
  7. There’s No Place Like Home

    Do it yourself, Home Depot said to Chinese customers. Go ___ yourself, said Chinese customers to Home Depot. Several years ago, when Home Depot set up 12 stores in China, it had high hopes of winning over Chinese to the joys of hands-on home...
    Date2012.11.22 Views4404 file
    Read More
  8. What Peter Drucker Would Be Reading

    Recent selections from around the web that, we think, would have caught Peter Drucker’s eye: 1. Phasing Out Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac: Is It Being Done Responsibly? Not many of us have warm feelings for Freddie or Fannie, but they’ve been a...
    Date2012.11.22 Views4284 file
    Read More
  9. Joe’s Journal: On Learning How to Learn

    “Managing oneself is a REVOLUTION in human affairs. It requires new and unprecedented things from the individual, and especially from the knowledge worker. For, in effect, it demands that each knowledge worker think and behave as a chief ex...
    Date2012.11.22 Views4982 file
    Read More
  10. Competitive Edge

    Forget the recession. At least for a moment. According to Harvard Magazine, the “real problem, obscured by this acute, cyclical downturn, may be a long-term erosion of competitiveness in a more challenging global economic era.” The United St...
    Date2012.11.22 Views3711 file
    Read More
Board Pagination ‹ Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... 12 Next ›
/ 12

Designed by sketchbooks.co.kr / sketchbook5 board skin

나눔글꼴 설치 안내


이 PC에는 나눔글꼴이 설치되어 있지 않습니다.

이 사이트를 나눔글꼴로 보기 위해서는
나눔글꼴을 설치해야 합니다.

설치 취소

Sketchbook5, 스케치북5

Sketchbook5, 스케치북5

Sketchbook5, 스케치북5

Sketchbook5, 스케치북5

(우)463-400 경기도 성남시 분당구 판교로 255번길 64 아이코닉스빌딩 3층
☎ 02-563-0005 FAX 02-562-0002
Copyright (c)Copyright 2010 NPI All rights reserved. All Right Reserved.
XE Login